Opinion: Internet Pact to ‘Combat All Forms of Intolerance’ Raises Concerns

 

In a move denounced by some as “Orwellian,” Facebook, Twitter, Youtube, and Microsoft have all pledged to review and remove illegal hate speech from their platforms within 24 hours of receiving notification.

This initiative signifies the beginning of a partnership between major tech giants and the European Commission, which is encouraging the tech companies to “combat all forms of intolerance” by cracking down on what the Commission considers to be hate speech.  The agreement also advises tech companies to promote and encourage “counter and alternatives narratives” that are presumably favored by the European Commission.

As private corporations, technology companies certainly have the right to issue guidelines for the use of their platforms and censor speech that does not conform to their guidelines. What is concerning, however, is the collusion between private companies and a governmental body.

Though officials from the European Commission and the tech companies involved insist that the purpose of the partnership is to restrict the ability of terrorists to disseminate their message through social media, many fear that speech deemed politically incorrect may also be censored.

In a statement, Janice Atkinson, an independent Member of European Parliament who represents Southeast England, called the partnership between the tech companies and the European Commission “Orwellian,” adding that, “anyone who has read 1984 sees it’s [sic] very re-enactment live.”

European Digital Rights, an international human rights advocacy organization headquartered in Brussels, also issued a statement against the partnership and decided to withdraw from further conversations with the European Commission.

The agreement, which directs tech companies to remove illegal hate speech online in Europe, fails to appreciate that the internet is global in nature. Posts, comments, and videos originating from the United States are accessible in Europe, and vice versa. It remains to be seen whether tech companies will differentiate between speech originating in Europe, where various forms of “hate speech” is illegal, and speech from elsewhere, where that same speech is not illegal.

Unlike much of Europe, the U.S. Constitution guarantees freedom of speech, even protecting hate speech so long as it does not contain actual threats of illegal conduct.  In R.A.V. v. St. Paul (1992), the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously held that ordinances which prohibit certain types of unfavorable and distasteful speech about race, creed, or gender are unconstitutional.

Facebook found itself in the midst of controversy earlier this month when former employees alleged that the social media juggernaut was removing news stories published by conservative organizations from its “trending” news section. In 2013, the company received criticism for blocking the personal page of Fox News contributor Todd Starnes after he posted a status in which he mentioned Paula Deen, Cracker Barrel, Chick-fil-A, and the Bible. Other examples of Facebook’s perceived discrimination against conservatives can be found here.

What do you think? Chime in using the comments section below.

Blaine Conzatti is a columnist and 2016 Research Fellow at the Family Policy Institute of Washington. He can be reached at Blaine@FPIW.org.

7 replies
  1. epson printer support number
    epson printer support number says:

    If You facing any issues from your epson printer and you finding reliable customer support for epson. So you are in right place. We providing a technical support for epson printer. We have microsoft certified technician team who is able to solve any problem regarding to your epson printer. Just dial our epson printer toll free number for support 1800-4360-0509

    Reply
  2. harry
    harry says:

    We at Epson Printer Support have an incredible recognition of being the satisfactory Epson restore center in the marketplace for supplying our clients with the satisfactory in class services. Our incredibly skilled experts can take care of any printer associated trouble and troubleshoot it with brief answers. We have a toll unfastened helpline range +1-877-760-6111 at which you could name to clarify your printer concerns and avail easy and short answers from our specialists.
    https://www.epsonprintersupport247.com/fix-epson-printer-offline/

    Reply
  3. Printer in Error State HP
    Printer in Error State HP says:

    Hey, this was great, thanks for taking the time to write it.Your Article gives me great knowledge. I am totally satisfied with your work. If your HP Printer is In Error State, reach us back. Our expert team will resolve all the issues how to solve error state in HP Printer. Printer in error state,” It means there may be a problem with the printer itself. Make sure the printer is turned on and connected to your laptop or desktop, by Wi-Fi or cable. Check it for low paper or ink, and be sure the cover isn’t open and the paper isn’t jammed. For more information you can click below mentioned link.

    Reply
  4. http://callsupporthelpline.com
    http://callsupporthelpline.com says:

    Upon hearing the term ‘third party”, the users normally think of outsourcing and the cost benefits that are often lauded as the chief benefit. But users should also know that the third party options typically are more cost-effective and are cheaper as compared to house options.

    Reply
  5. Apple Support
    Apple Support says:

    Thanks for sharing the methods to solve the overheating issue of the laptop. i am using the apple laptop and it gets overheated while using. I use your methods and apply to solve the overheating issue. it is really helped me. In case if any other apple laptop issue occurs visit apple support for the solution.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.